Dating Site Review

CatholicMatch Review

 July 28, 2020

By  Dating Site Guides

CatholicMatch Review - Is It Worth It?

A CatholicMatch review has to address the faith-based dating scene. Although today’s society seems less and less engaged with religion, there are still large groups of people that prefer to date within the faith, especially when it comes to marriage.

Sunday service is slightly different at each church and so are the religious practices between different Christian groups. It is understandable that Catholics that are ready to settle down and raise a family look for someone with the same traditions and values.

There are several popular Christian dating sites but if you are looking for a truly engaged Catholic community this could be the best choice for you. The language and profile options are clearly geared towards the Catholic community but there are no requirements as to how devout someone is.

The singles on CatholicMatch are looking for a serious relationship, mostly with the intention of marriage. Over the years, many churches have relaxed their policies and accept marriages between Christians of different denominations.

This brings us to the most important question of this review: Is CatholicMatch better than more inclusive Christian dating sites? Keep reading our CatholicMatch review to find out.

  • Active Deals

  • User Base

  • Popularity

  • Gender Ratio

Signup Process

Signing up for CatholicMatch is relatively quick. You only need a few minutes to get started.

Registration requires verification of either an e-mail address or Facebook account. This is one of the ways that the website keeps out fake accounts.

You’ll spend most of your time answering questions about your beliefs and Christian practices. This is a requirement for registration.

You don’t have have to write full essays so you can get through these questions relatively fast. However, since they are rather deep and personal questions, don’t rush through them either.

Another requirement is uploading a profile picture. Those that sign up via their Facebook account can choose to use their Facebook profile photo. This way you don’t have to upload a new one.

One unusual step in registration is getting a username. This is another safety precaution but it also makes the online dating experience feel less personal.

All members get an automatically generated username. It is your first name plus your membership number.

As for pricing, CatholicMatch is one of the most affordable online dating sites. If you sign up for the 12 month membership you are paying about the same as a Netflix account.

There is another perk related to pricing. CatholicMatch offers its members 6 months extra for free if they did not find any potential matches within 6 months.

If you want to get the full experience, you have to upgrade to a paid membership. Free members can only send an emotigram - no messages or replying to messages.

Well, this is not completely true. Free members can reply to a message but they can only do so 10 days after the message has been sent.

In the online dating world, 10 days is a very long wait to talk to someone. On the other hand, if you do continue to interact after these 10 days you at least know that that person has the Christian virtue of patience.

Creating Your Personal Profile

After the initial registration process, it is time to complete your profile. You already cover the basics such as which diocese you belong to during registration.

In this next step, you get the opportunity to provide more information about your faith. Examples include how you came into the religion and which of the Church’s teachings you follow.

You also get more general questions about for example your hobbies, favorite foods and how you feel about long distance relationships. If you fill everything out, you end up with a very detailed profile.

One of the advantages of joining CatholicMatch is that you have full control over what is and what is not available for other members to see. For every question that you answer on your profile, you have the option to mark it as ‘get to know me better’. This option lets you keep the answer private until you feel comfortable with the person.

Members can take the Temperament Quiz which is similar to a personality test. The Temperament Quiz is an external service and you will be taken to a different website.

Essentially, the Temperament Quiz classify people into 4 different personality types: Choleric, Phlegmatic, Melancholic and Sanguine. This is supposed to give you an insight into whether your personalities are compatible or not.

After you complete the quiz, the results are published on your profile. Unlike with matching algorithms, it is completely up to you to decide whether your personalities are actually compatible. There are no suggested matches from CatholicMatch.

Pricing & Account-Level Features

  • FREE


Free Account Features

  • Registration
  • Setting up a profile
  • Like maximum of 3 profiles per day
  • Search profiles
  • See who viewed your profile
  • Read messages but only reply after 10 days
  • Reading forum posts

Making Connections on CatholicMatch

As a free member, there aren’t very many ways to make a connection with someone on CatholicMatch. Whereas many other online dating sites let free members interact on the public forums, CatholicMatch only lets free members read the posts.

The only way that a free member can interact is when a paid member sends them a message first. Even then, you have to wait 10 days to be able to reply.

So, if you are serious about finding a love match then you will need to upgrade your account on CatholicMatch. Once you do, you get to send unlimited messages, gain insight into member activity and even receive personalized coaching on online dating.

Starting your search for love on CatholicMatch probably begins with a customized profile search. Every single profile question that you had to fill in is also a search option.

The many faith-based questions lets you browse for profiles that are on the same wavelength as you. Chances are that faith is a central element of your life if you are a CatholicMatch member so it only makes sense that you can search for profiles based on faith, too.

Besides the Temperament Quiz that we mentioned earlier in this CatholicMatch review, there is also the Match Portrait, essentially a matching algorithm. The Match Portrait function asks you a series of questions relating to how you see your future and which morals and values you find important in a relationship.

Since the goal of this faith-based dating site is finding a life partner, you can expect very profound questions. Following the teachings of the Catholic faith, men and women should find intimacy in marriage and for marriage to be on the table you need a deep connection.

After completing the questions, you are shown a list of profiles with compatible views. Click on the profiles that you like so that you will receive a notification if that person is interested in you, as well.

Besides making a romantic connection, CatholicMatch also encourages a faith-based connection. Their online community is very engaged with thousands of daily forum posts that you can interact with.

The forum is a great way to meet other Catholics in your neighborhood. It is also an opportunity to discuss what it is like dating as a Catholic with your peers.

CatholicMatch Pros & Cons

  • PROS

  • Cons

  • Free registration
  • Option to take photos from Facebook
  • Very engaged Catholic community
  • Paid membership gives access to dating advice
  • Option for both personal search and suggested matches
  • Faith-based search options
  • Free 6 month extension if no match is found within 6 months
  • Mobile app available
  • Members are most interested in marriage
  • Control over what information shows on your profile


What is CatholicMatch?

CatholicMatch is an online dating site specifically for single Catholics looking for serious relationships and marriage.

Who Owns CatholicMatch?

The founders of the website are Brian Barcaro, Jason LaFosse and Mike Lloyd. Barcaro and LaFosse ran smaller dating site called saintraphael.net but then launched CatholicMatch after meeting with Lloyd.

Is Catholic Match Any Good?

This is one of the most popular Catholic dating sites. Their website boasts plenty of success stories including many marriages. If you are a Catholic and ready to settle down to raise a family then you have good chances of finding a match on this website.

Is CatholicMatch Safe?

Yes, CatholicMatch is a very safe online dating site. Their website admin monitors for suspicious behaviour 24/7. Any profiles showing suspicious behaviour will be removed. Members can send a report to the customer service team when they wish to block a person.

Are There Success Stories?

Yes, you can find plenty of success stories on the CatholicMatch website. Simply click on the Success Stories button on the website and you will be able to scroll through countless accounts from happy couples. New success stories are constantly added which shows that this online dating site continues to be effective.

Can I Block Someone on CatholicMatch?

You cannot block someone directly on CatholicMatch but you can report a person to the customer service team. The customer service team will set up the profile block for you.

How Much Is CatholicMatch?

The membership fee for CatholicMatch depends on the length of the membership. There are 1 month, 6 months and 12 months options.

As is standard with online dating sites, the longer the membership the more affordable it becomes. CatholicMatch offers discounts for membership extensions.

Can I Hide My Profile?

Yes, paid memberships lets you hide your profile for a maximum of 180 days.

CatholicMatch Testimonial

Final Verdict & Review

The continuous flood of success stories alone is proof that CatholicMatch is a very good online dating site. The way that they set up their service is effective in bringing Catholics together for marriage.

The website itself is uncluttered, straightforward and easy to navigate. Unlike many other niche dating sites it looks modern and is not covered with ad space.

Although the Catholic church is often viewed as a very traditional community, this online dating site offers Catholic singles a safe and comfortable place to date in the modern age. Overall, it is a very pleasant experience with great emphasis on building faith-based connections.

The only downside is a small one; long distance dating is likely if you live in a smaller town. Still, true love conquers all and from what we can see, CatholicMatch offers Catholics all they need to find their true love.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}